Are Holy Wars Coming to America?

I overheard a brief conversation between two Protestant friends a few days ago.

“Have you been following the destruction and chaos caused by radical Muslims in Europe?”

“Yes,” the other replied. “Have you noticed how their extremist groups have been growing in America?”

“I know. It’s crazy. Maybe the Crusades happened for a reason.”

That last comment caught me off guard. As a Catholic convert, I'm accustomed to defending the Crusades to Protestant friends. But this was the first time I'd overheard someone suggest that perhaps they understood why they happened. And it got me thinking, are we entering a period in history where religious tensions simmering elsewhere could come to America—even religious war?

The Crusades weren't simply a bunch of Christians waking up one morning and deciding to invade a peaceful Muslim world. The First Crusade, launched in 1095, came partly in response to an appeal from the Byzantine Empire for military assistance against advancing Seljuk Turks. It was also an effort to secure access to the Holy Land and protect Christian communities and pilgrims. From a Catholic perspective, the Crusades were understood as armed pilgrimages, penitential acts, and military efforts to defend or recover Christian territories and sacred places. They were shaped by the medieval understanding of warfare and religion.

Were the Crusades perfect? Absolutely not. Atrocities were committed, Jewish communities were massacred, civilians were killed, and the Fourth Crusade ended with the devastating sack of Constantinople—a Christian city! We shouldn't excuse those actions, but neither should we reduce centuries of complicated history to a simplistic caricature of Christians waging unprovoked war against Muslims. Now, the Crusades aren't a template for modern Christianity, but the question of whether Christian societies have the right to defend their people, laws, freedoms, and institutions is hardly obsolete.

Europe has grappled with terrorism and religious extremism for years, coinciding with a significant rise in Muslim immigration. Pew Research estimated that Muslims made up approximately 6% of Europe's population in 2020. That growth, in itself, is not a threat, millions of Muslims are peaceful people who work, raise families, and simply want to live their lives. But radical Islamist movements do exist and some openly advocate religiously governed political systems—even in America.

Sharia is an Islamic religious and moral framework governing everything from worship and personal conduct to family life and, in some interpretations, criminal and political law. While many Muslims view it primarily as a guide to personal faith, some Islamist movements advocate making Islamic law superior to secular legislation—including American law. Now, no American state has yet adopted Sharia as a legal system superseding the Constitution. Muslims are free to practice their religion, just like Christians and Jews. But religious freedom is one thing; replacing American constitutional law with a religious legal system is another.

Meanwhile, something interesting is happening among some younger Americans, men in particular. Gallup recently reported that monthly religious service attendance among men ages 18–29 rose from 33% in 2022–2023 to 40% in 2024–2025. Some young men are searching for discipline, purpose, brotherhood, and something bigger than themselves, and some are finding it in Christianity. I hope they're finding more than a political identity, I hope they're finding Christ—the Christ who calls men to courage, sacrifice, humility, self-control, and love of their enemies. But are these young men being drawn to the church for another reason? Most of the violence committed by Muslims is done by “military aged men.” Is a counter offense of young Christian men being assembled?

For centuries, Catholics and Protestants have viewed one another with suspicion, sometimes hostility. The divisions weren't merely theological, they were cultural, political, and personal. Anti-Catholic prejudice was widespread in early America, and Catholics faced discrimination, restrictions, and sometimes violence. Yet Christianity profoundly shaped America's cultural and moral development. Protestant traditions influenced much of its early religious culture, while Catholics contributed enormously to its institutions, education, charitable work, neighborhoods, and civic life.

Now we've spent five centuries arguing over Scripture, tradition, the papacy, justification, sacraments, and the saints. Some disagreements remain significant, and I'm not suggesting we pretend otherwise, but something has changed. The internet has made it possible for Protestants to hear educated Catholics explain what they actually believe—and for Catholics to hear educated Protestants do the same. We don't have to rely on caricatures passed down through generations anymore. I don't expect the Reformation's disagreements to disappear, but I think we're increasingly able to recognize one another as fellow Christians rather than enemies. We have enough genuine challenges facing Christianity without inventing enemies within the Body of Christ.

Are old alliances being reforged to combat a common enemy?

Catholics and Protestants aren't the only Christians making progress toward reconciliation. The Catholic and Eastern Orthodox Churches have been divided for centuries, traditionally associated with 1054, though the separation developed over a much longer period. Disagreements over authority and Trinitarian theology contributed to the divide. One of the most painful events was the sack of Constantinople in 1204 by Western crusaders, which deepened the wounds between Eastern and Western Christians. But reconciliation efforts have been underway for decades.

In 1964, St. Pope John Paul II and Ecumenical Patriarch Athenagoras met in Jerusalem. In 1965, they jointly removed the mutual excommunications associated with the events of 1054. This didn't restore communion, but it was a historic step. In 2025, Pope Leo XIV (fellow Chicagoan—sorry) and Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew reaffirmed their commitment to dialogue and Christian unity.

If Catholics, Protestants, and Orthodox can increasingly recognize their common faith in Christ, perhaps that's one of the most important developments happening in Christianity today. And the Holy Spirit may be prompting this for a reason.

So, Are the Holy Wars Coming to America?

I don't know. And neither does anyone else. I'm not hoping for a holy war. Christians are called to love their neighbors, pray for their enemies, seek peace, and protect the innocent. But loving our neighbors doesn't require pretending evil doesn't exist. Seeking peace doesn't mean surrendering our principles.

If the West faces an increasingly dangerous period, Christians will need courage, discernment, and a firm understanding of what we believe. Perhaps the most important thing we can do right now is to stop fighting one another over misunderstandings and recognize the common faith we share. Catholics, Protestants, and Orthodox don't have to agree on every theological question to recognize that Jesus Christ is Lord, the Gospel is true, we’re all part of His one body, and that the world desperately needs Him.

I don't know what the future holds for America, Europe, or Christianity. Maybe we're heading toward a revival, maybe persecution, probably toward something none of us can imagine. And no, I'm not hoping for a holy war, I'm hoping for a holy revival. Men and women willing to stand firmly in their faith, defend truth, protect the innocent, love their enemies, and refuse to compromise the Gospel.

I'm not looking for a fight, but I'm not afraid of one either. Christ is victorious, and I'm with Him.

 

Sources: The Crusades (1095–1291) — The Metropolitan Museum of Art. Historical overview of the Crusades, their origins, motivations, and consequences. The Future of Religion in Europe, 2020–2070 — Pew Research Center. Demographic projections for Christianity, Islam, and the religiously unaffiliated in Europe. EU Terrorism Situation and Trend Report (TE-SAT) — Europol. Annual reporting on terrorism trends, including jihadist terrorism, right-wing terrorism, and other ideological forms of terrorism. Catholic Answers Magazine — Catholic.com. Rise in Young Men's Religiosity Realigns Gender Gaps — Gallup. Recent survey data regarding religious importance, affiliation, and attendance among young American men and women. The First Amendment and Religious Freedom — Library of Congress. Historical background on religious freedom and the constitutional framework governing religion in the United States. Joint Catholic-Orthodox Declaration, December 7, 1965 — Vatican. The joint declaration of Pope Paul VI and Ecumenical Patriarch Athenagoras I regarding the mutual excommunications of 1054.

Next
Next

Are Evangelicals Swarming to Catholicism?